Great, if you have a bare Apple Pencil
On Dec 27, 2018 At Amazon.com
I bought this, because it appeared strong and slim. That it is. However, it was impossible to see from the pictures and wasn't in the description that the indentation for the pencil didn't even include enough extra room for a nib cover, let alone a silicone cover for the slippery Apple Pencil. It is being returned. I'm sad, because I wanted to love it! If you use your Apple Pencil without a sleeve or nib cover, etc., it will be perfect for you.
Best case for Apple Pencil.
On Nov 28, 2018 At Amazon.com
Case is slim. Pencil (I use 2nd gen) fits amazing well. The case snaps shut strongly, and it appears to offer great protection.